Things to Do in Stella Maris, Long Island

Consistently rated among the most beautiful beaches in the world, Cape Santa Maria stretches for miles with powdery white sand and crystal-clear turquoise water. The sheltered bay creates calm swimming conditions while the remote location ensures crowds are never a concern.

Tip: Pack a picnic as there are no vendors on this pristine stretch.

Located about a mile offshore from Cape Santa Maria, Shark Reef delivers thrilling encounters with Caribbean reef sharks in their natural habitat. The site features dramatic coral formations and abundant marine life beyond the sharks. Visibility typically exceeds 100 feet.

Tip: Bring an underwater camera for close shark encounters.

Also known as Cartwright's Cave, this extensive cave system ranks among the most impressive in the Bahamas. The limestone formations include dramatic stalactites and evidence of Lucayan habitation. Guided tours reveal both geological wonders and archaeological significance.

James Docky Smith has earned recognition as one of the finest bonefishing guides in the Bahamas. His decades of experience on Long Island's flats translate to exceptional catch rates. The pristine waters around Stella Maris offer ideal conditions for sight-fishing.

Tip: Book well in advance as his calendar fills quickly.

Miles of mangrove channels wind through the coastline near Stella Maris, creating protected waterways perfect for kayak exploration. The ecosystems teem with juvenile fish, wading birds, and occasional manatee sightings. Paddle to Newton's Cay for unique wildlife encounters.

These stone ruins tell the story of Long Island's plantation era, when cotton and other crops were cultivated by enslaved people. Walking tours reveal the layout of the former estate and provide historical context about the Bahamas' colonial past.

The world's third deepest blue hole lies within easy reach of Stella Maris, plunging 663 feet into the earth. Stella Maris Water Sports offers guided snorkeling and diving excursions to this extraordinary natural wonder. Even viewing from the surface impresses visitors.

Tip: Combine with a visit to nearby Clarence Town for lunch.

Every Friday at Stella Maris Resort, guests and locals gather for complimentary rum punch, conch fritters, and live music. The weekly tradition has become an institution, offering the best opportunity to mingle with Long Island's community and hear local musicians.

Tip: Arrive early as the conch fritters go fast.

Located in nearby Deadman's Cay, this small museum preserves Long Island's history through artifacts, photographs, and documents. Exhibits cover Lucayan culture, the plantation era, and modern island life, providing essential context for understanding this distinctive place.